Settle it in the comments — friendships tested weekly — no wrong answers, only strongly held ones
Est. Retirement Day  •  2026

Todd Talks Tackle

The Great Debates: where tackle boxes become soap boxes.

In This Corner…

The Great Tackle Debates

Every fisherman has a hill to die on. Each week I pick a fight, make the case for both sides, then let the comments sort it out. Click a corner to cast your vote.

Round 14 — This Week 💬 87 comments and climbing

Braided Line

Zero stretch, feels everything, casts a mile, lasts for seasons. You can finally tell the difference between a bite and a weed.

Todd's pick — "fight me"
VS

Monofilament

Forgiving, invisible, cheap, and it's landed more fish than every braid spool ever wound. That stretch saves fish — and knuckles.

Ray the Guide's pick
Braid — 58%
Mono — 42%
click a corner to vote — the bar moves, the arguments don't
Round 13 💬 132 comments — record holder

Live Bait

Fish eat food, not jewellery. When the bite is tough, nothing on the wall of lures beats the real thing. That's not opinion, that's biology.

The dock consensus
VS

Artificial Lures

Skill over groceries. A lure fisherman is hunting, not waiting. And you never have to explain the smell in the garage fridge.

Todd's pick — "it's an art"
Live Bait — 44%
Lures — 56%
click a corner to vote
Round 12 💬 64 comments

One Rod, Mastered

Learn one setup so well it becomes an extension of your arm. The old timers ran one rod for decades and out-fished everybody.

The minimalist's creed
VS

A Rod for Every Job

Right tool, right water. You wouldn't frame a house with one hammer. Yes, the boat looks like a porcupine. It's called being prepared.

Todd's pick — obviously
One Rod — 37%
Many Rods — 63%
click a corner to vote

Got a Hill to Die On?

Send me your debate topic. If it starts an argument at the marina, it makes the show.

Suggest a debate

The Weekly Bite

Next week's debate lands in your inbox first. — Todd